Last January the California Legislature passed SB931 which barred first lenders that consent to short sales from having any deficiency recourse against the borrowers. However, they quickly learned that it is junior lenders (seconds, HELOCS, etc.) that control the success of short sales. So on July 15th, the Legislature passed SB458 imposing the same recourse bar on junior lenders plus they barred any lender from requiring a money contribution from the sellers. These law changes created and then amended California Code of Civil Procedure Section 580e.
The conclusion at this point is that there is still a lot of uncertainty in the market, particularly amongst lenders trying to understand and respond to SB458. However, here are the main benefits emerging:
1. SB458 forces junior lenders to evaluate right now whether or not they could collect from a borrower if they waited for the first lender to foreclose and then sued as a sold-out junior lienholder. Prior to SB458, the junior lender could get some money in the short sale while holding out for recourse on the balance. They could then wait this out for several years and hope the borrower gets solvent. Not any more. Clearly this makes the borrower’s hardship application and particularly their net worth statement even more important in the decision making process.
2. SB458 appears to have brought an additional liability protection for borrowers who agreed to a prior short sale with deficiency recourse. The first Paragraph of the new short sale law begins: “No deficiency shall be owed or collected, and no deficiency judgment shall be requested or rendered…..” Nothing in SB458 states that it only applies to short sales after July 15th.
No doubt there will be a lot more debate and analysis and litigation concerning SB458 and its impacts. As with any law, it will be subject to judicial review in the courts and further change, expansion, and clarification by the Legislature. But for now, CCP580e is the law of the State of California.
The information presented in this Article is not to be taken as legal advice. Every person’s situation is different. If you have specific questions about dealing with upside down loans or real estate, be sure to contact a real estate attorney in your State.
Please Click Here if you have additional questions and if we can assist in Selling your home.
The conclusion at this point is that there is still a lot of uncertainty in the market, particularly amongst lenders trying to understand and respond to SB458. However, here are the main benefits emerging:
1. SB458 forces junior lenders to evaluate right now whether or not they could collect from a borrower if they waited for the first lender to foreclose and then sued as a sold-out junior lienholder. Prior to SB458, the junior lender could get some money in the short sale while holding out for recourse on the balance. They could then wait this out for several years and hope the borrower gets solvent. Not any more. Clearly this makes the borrower’s hardship application and particularly their net worth statement even more important in the decision making process.
2. SB458 appears to have brought an additional liability protection for borrowers who agreed to a prior short sale with deficiency recourse. The first Paragraph of the new short sale law begins: “No deficiency shall be owed or collected, and no deficiency judgment shall be requested or rendered…..” Nothing in SB458 states that it only applies to short sales after July 15th.
No doubt there will be a lot more debate and analysis and litigation concerning SB458 and its impacts. As with any law, it will be subject to judicial review in the courts and further change, expansion, and clarification by the Legislature. But for now, CCP580e is the law of the State of California.
The information presented in this Article is not to be taken as legal advice. Every person’s situation is different. If you have specific questions about dealing with upside down loans or real estate, be sure to contact a real estate attorney in your State.
Please Click Here if you have additional questions and if we can assist in Selling your home.
No comments:
Post a Comment